I suppose there was a need for this book. Crisis On Infinite Earths had made the JLA's origin obsolete. Things needed to be shuffled around to make it still work. And this book put it all down on paper for us. I remember enjoying the book when it first came out all those years ago. But reading it with a fresh set of eyes, all these years later, I kind of feel like this story is a big waste of time. In the years since it was published, this story, too, has become obsolete. Events have made changes in history and this doesn't hold up anymore. And maybe that's why I feel like it was a waste? I don't know.
There were a lot of things that bothered me about this book. I love an Easter egg, but it felt like this book when above and beyond the call of duty to shove as many of them in here as possible. It's distracting. Some of the characterizations also annoyed me. Black Canary especially. She was insufferable to me.
I heard a lot of behind the scenes stuff about the production of this book back when it was being published. There was a lot of talk about Mark Waid being furious with Brian Augustyn's scripting and that he had to rescript an awful lot of this book. It may be true. I've never been a big Augustyn fan. I don't feel he's a very good writer. It may be his presence here that brings the book down for me. Because it's not Waid. He's still got a million ideas and they're all good.
It was nice to revisit this book, but I don't know if it was necessary.
JLA Year One: The Deluxe Edition
Writer: Mark Waid, Brian Augustyn
Artist: Barry Kitson, Michael Bair, Mark Propst, John Stokes
DC Comics
No comments:
Post a Comment